Sarah is a cautious planner. She’s just bought her first home and locked in a fixed-rate mortgage. She loves the certainty of knowing exactly what her monthly payments will be, even if interest rates skyrocket. For her, peace of mind is priceless—no surprises, just steady, predictable payments. However, a year later, interest rates plummet, and her friends with variable-rate mortgages are paying hundreds less per month. Sarah’s happy to avoid the risk, but sometimes wonders, “What if?”

Story 2: Mike’s Gamble

Mike, on the other hand, thrives on flexibility. He went with a variable-rate mortgage because the starting interest rate was lower, and he liked the idea of saving more if rates stayed low. For a while, it was great—extra cash in his pocket for vacations and investments. But then rates began creeping up, and his payments started increasing. Mike had to adjust his budget on the fly. He says it keeps things interesting, but admits the unpredictability is stressful.

Breaking it Down: Fixed vs. Variable

Here’s a quick comparison to show how much your choice could cost over 5 years (assuming a $300,000 mortgage with a 25-year amortization).

Factors to Consider

1. Risk Tolerance: Are you like Sarah, who prefers stability, or Mike, who’s willing to gamble for potential savings?
2. Economic Trends: If interest rates are expected to rise, fixed rates might save you money in the long run.
3. Flexibility: Variable rates often allow you to switch to fixed later, but you need to stay on top of changes.
4. Current Rates: Compare the fixed and starting variable rates—how big is the gap?

Takeaway

If you’re not sure what to pick, think about your personality and financial situation. Would an unexpected hike in payments cause major stress? Then fixed might be better. But if you’re okay with riding the wave of changing rates, variable could be your chance to save.

So, are you more of a Sarah or a Mike?

1. Fixed vs. Variable Mortgages: Which One Fits Your Style?
2. Mortgage Matchup: Are You a Sarah or a Mike?

Over the past 20 years, Australian mortgage customers have faced a tricky decision when choosing between fixed and variable interest rates. Historical data reveals that this decision depends largely on economic trends, personal risk tolerance, and market conditions.

Historical Context: Fixed vs. Variable Rates

From the early 2000s to 2008, variable rates were often advantageous due to steady rate declines. For instance, after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2008, variable rates dropped sharply as the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) reduced the cash rate to support economic recovery. Fixed-rate borrowers during this time often missed out on these savings. Conversely, those who locked in fixed rates before the GFC (e.g., 2005-2007) avoided steep hikes that peaked around 2008 at approximately 9%​

​

.

In the 2010s, variable rates were more volatile but generally lower than fixed rates until late 2020, when the RBA’s quantitative easing made fixed rates very appealing. More recently, rising rates since 2022 have made fixed rates a safer choice for those worried about unpredictable hikes​

​

.

Real Stories

• Emma’s Fixed-Rate Strategy: In 2019, Emma opted for a three-year fixed-rate mortgage at 3.5%. By 2022, variable rates had surged above 5%, and Emma was relieved to have stable payments. However, she couldn’t take advantage of early repayment flexibility and had to wait until her term ended to refinance.
• James’ Variable Bet: James chose a variable rate in 2014 when the RBA’s cash rate was trending downward. His gamble paid off, saving thousands as rates fell. However, in 2023, rising rates pushed his payments significantly higher, forcing budget cuts.

Table of Comparison

The table below illustrates how different scenarios impact the total cost of a $500,000 mortgage over five years.

Key Takeaways

1. Economic Trends: Fixed rates are advantageous when rates are expected to rise, as seen in the current environment.
2. Flexibility vs. Certainty: Variable rates offer savings during rate drops but come with higher risk.
3. Short-Term vs. Long-Term Goals: If refinancing or selling within a few years, a variable rate might save you money if rates are stable​
   Mortgage Professional

   ​

   OwnHome | Low Deposit Home Loans

   .

Whether you’re an Emma or a James depends on your financial situation and tolerance for risk. Watching trends and consulting mortgage brokers can help make the right call.

When it comes to mortgages, Australians have historically favored variable rates, but fixed rates have gained traction in certain periods, especially during times of economic uncertainty or rising interest rates. Let’s break this down with some history and relatable examples to see how preferences have shifted over the past 20 years.

A Look at Australian Mortgage Rates Over Time

1. 2000s to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC):
   Variable rates were king. From the early 2000s to 2008, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) kept cutting the cash rate, which meant borrowers with variable-rate mortgages saw their payments drop. For example, before the GFC, variable rates hovered around 8-9%, but they sharply dropped as the RBA reduced rates to stimulate the economy​

   Orange Finance

   ​

   OwnHome | Low Deposit Home Loans

   .

    

2. Post-GFC Recovery (2010–2019):
   Rates stayed low, making variable rates an attractive choice for those who wanted flexibility and the potential for further cuts. However, some borrowers chose fixed rates during brief periods of anticipated rate hikes, but these were often a smaller portion of the market​

   Mortgage Professional

   ​

   OwnHome | Low Deposit Home Loans

   .

    

3. Pandemic and Beyond (2020–2023):
   Fixed rates became highly popular during the pandemic. In 2020-21, the RBA introduced record-low interest rates and bond-buying programs, pushing fixed rates down significantly—some as low as 2%. Many borrowers locked in these historically low rates to shield themselves from future increases. By late 2022, as the RBA began aggressively hiking rates to combat inflation, variable-rate borrowers saw sharp payment increases​

   Mortgage Professional

   ​

   OwnHome | Low Deposit Home Loans

   .

    

Real-Life Stories

• Claire’s Variable-Rate Win (2015):
  Claire bought her first home in 2015 and went with a variable rate at 4.5%. Over the next few years, rates dropped, reducing her payments significantly. She used the extra money to renovate her house, feeling great about her choice. However, she knew this approach came with risks if rates rose suddenly.

• Dave’s Fixed-Rate Safety (2021):
  Dave locked in a three-year fixed rate at 2.2% in 2021. While his friends with variable loans are now scrambling to adjust budgets as rates climb above 6%, Dave enjoys steady payments. He admits he misses the opportunity to pay off his mortgage faster due to the lack of flexibility but values the predictability during uncertain times.

Why Choose One Over the Other?

Takeaway

Australians have leaned towards variable rates during times of stability and falling rates, but fixed rates see spikes in popularity when rates are low or volatile, like in 2020-21. Choosing the right option depends on your financial goals, tolerance for risk, and the broader economic environment.

Whether you’re a “Claire” enjoying flexibility or a “Dave” seeking certainty, keeping an eye on RBA trends and working with mortgage advisors can help you make the best decision​

​

.